Real debate needed over presidential election

Even before they start their Third Level or working lives, the 55,000 students who received their Leaving Cert results last Wednesday have done the people of the State a service. Acres of coverage of their achievements meant that, yesterday, most of the main national newspapers, including The Mail, were Presidential campaign free zones. What a relief.

Even before they start their Third Level or working lives, the 55,000 students who received their Leaving Cert results last Wednesday have done the people of the State a service. Acres of coverage of their achievements meant that, yesterday, most of the main national newspapers, including The Mail, were Presidential campaign free zones. What a relief.

Anecdotal evidence strongly suggests that very many of our citizens have already succumbed to presidential campaign fever fatigue. No wonder, for why should they tolerate being force fed coverage by the square kilometre of an office for which the main qualifications are that the incumbent be able to warmly shake hands, look solemn while walking up and down ceremonial lines of stern faced soldiers and sound sincere during the endless recitation of pious platitudes.

News editors looking to fill blank pages while many of the usual news makers are on holiday, will probably mean the respite will be short lived. Still it gives an opportunity to reflect on the absurdity that is the office of President of Ireland. And the hypocrisy of the political establishment toward that office.

The three political parties that have dominated political life in the State since its inception have colluded in a major deception surrounding the presidency. They proclaim loudly that the office is ‘above politics’ even as they frantically jockey for political advantage in trying to get their man or woman into the official residence in the Phoenix Park.

Each party will claim that their candidate embodies the values and policies that Ireland needs for the future. However even if this were true, no matter which candidate wins, once ensconced in the position, nothing meaningful can be heard about a future direction for the country since the President is constitutionally mandated to sing dumb on such issues. Should the President have any brilliant new insights into how the problems of our society might be overcome, they can never be communicated to the electorate because of a government ban – constitutionally provided for.

There is an argument that the presidency serves as a link for the diaspora, the millions of Irish born people abroad and their descendants. We should maintain solidarity with our people around the world, many of whom forced out by the failures of Irish capitalism, but we could do so with an Ambassador for the Diaspora, at a fraction of the cost and without the sham contest now going on.

And it is a sham, and highly undemocratic, since nomination procedures mean people will get to vote only for candidates who have been vetted by the political establishment. This is a time honoured, cynical ploy utilised by political elites the world over from the now defunct Stalinist bureaucracy in the Soviet Union to the ruling clique in present day Kazakhstan. For appearances a few token independents are allowed on to the ballot paper but nobody who stands for anything different or threatens the ruling establishment.

A measure of the irrelevancy of the campaign to date is that not one of the four declared candidates has had anything different to say on the critical economic crisis that is causing havoc in the lives of an enormous number of our people. Nothing about the immorality or unfairness of the Irish people being saddled with the crushing private debts of financial speculators and speculating developers. Nothing about the resulting catastrophic policy of Fine Gael, Labour and Fianna Fail, based on savage austerity and resulting in keeping almost half a million workers unemployed.

These are issues that will plague us for very many years to come. How these issues are dealt with will determine the future shape of Irish society. That includes whether tens of thousands of young people will be able to make a livelihood in their own country or be forced to emigrate. Surely any campaign for what is supposed to be the highest office in the land that doesn’t deal with them is a fraud and a waste of time and resources.

The fact that no candidate of the Left can get a nomination will mean that there will not be anything that could be termed a real debate on real alternatives regarding these critical economic and social issues. Instead we will have a continuation of the mind numbing and meaningless ramblings and talk about ‘vision’ and ‘hope’, concepts that are abstract nothings when divorced from plans and policies to bring about fundamental change that could transform the lives of the very many whose hopes are routinely dashed on the wreck that is the present financial and economic system.

Instead of a Presidential election on October 27, let’s have a Referendum to abolish this establishment bauble and in the meantime a real debate on real issues and real solutions to the disastrous failures of the present chaotic and crisis fuelled system.

 

Total
0
Shares
Previous Article

Water Charges Struggle: The lessons for today

Next Article

Socialist Party delegation travelling to Rossport to protest against Shell’s onshore pipeline

Related Posts
Read More

Privatisation lies behind Minister for Health scandal

There is only one real scandal involved in the issues surrounding Health Minister James Reilly’s problems arising from his investment in a private nursing home in County Tipperary. It is not because his name is in Stubbs Gazette as a debtor nor is it being in a financial conflict with those who invested with him in this project in 2010. The scandal is that the care of our elderly people in this State should be seen as a commercial opportunity for profit making through speculative investments by private commercial companies and individuals. An that this should be supported by massive tax breaks for wealthy investors.

Read More

Let them eat cake, not the crumbs off the table…

Business and media circles are agog at “the most significant development in philanthropy” for many decades. Forty US based billionaires have pledged to give half of their wealth to “charity” while living or on their death.

The “Giving Pledge” was initiated by two men said to be the richest in the world, Bill Gates founder of Microsoft, whose wealth is estimated to be about $40 billion and Warren Buffet coming in at $37 billion.

Read More

Child abuse – Irelands’ gulags

By Joe Higgins

Mary Raftery’s documentary, States of Fear, which gave rise to the Child Abuse Commission was first broadcast just over ten years ago, on Tuesday night, 27th April 1999. It was a shocking story, powerfully told but what happened the next morning in the Dail cast an interesting light on the ‘states of consciousness’ of the main political parties about the seriousness of what it had unearthed.